14 Comments
User's avatar
Gawain Barker's avatar

That's a good question - British noir's mother? The first book that springs to mind is Joolz Denby's Billie Morgan. I remember it as being 70s set but I see it's only 18 years old.

Expand full comment
Michael Blanton's avatar

I love Raymond and Lewis, both wonderful/excellent.

...I just found a bunch of Russell James books, nearly all of them in fact on Kindle, many for $2.99 US and not one over $3.99 US (picked up 10 crime novels, including Count Me Out, and a collection of short stories). FYI, James actually started writing crime novels in the late 80s, so Raymond and Lewis were writing crime novels well before him.

https://www.fantasticfiction.com/j/russell-james/

Expand full comment
Guy Salvidge's avatar

I read the Factory series out of order myself. The one you haven't read, The Devil's Home on Leave, is the one I read first. To me they are in declining order of merit based on composition ranging from outstanding to so-so. I have read The Hidden Files as well and it is certainly worth following up if you can source a copy. I think I paid $50 or so but that was 7-8 years ago.

I haven't bonded with Lewis as much although of course I love Get Carter the film. GBH I thought was a little overrated and in general I prefer Raymond. I've read the Getting Carter bio and it is a worthy read.

Expand full comment
Andrew Nette's avatar

I agree that the Factory series is patchy but I admire Raymond/Cook for just not giving a toss about the, until then, accepted conventions of the police procedural and I do not mind the unnamed narrators long winding musings on life and death, etc, because it is often so well written. On balance, I prefer Lewis and would rate him as the true progenitor of British noir fiction. I think Jack's Return Home/Get Carter was quite revolutionary. GBH is good but, for my money, Plender is Lewis's best novel. I reviewed it on my Pulp Curry site here: https://www.pulpcurry.com/2020/05/dirt-under-its-nails-ted-lewiss-plender/

Expand full comment
Guy Salvidge's avatar

Awesome I'll pick up a copy of Plender :)

Expand full comment
Brendan Long's avatar

The Hidden Files is wonderful. Essential reading.

Expand full comment
Andrew Nette's avatar

I am sure it is. I just need to find a copy that does not cost a fortune.

Expand full comment
Brendan Long's avatar

If I can locate my paperback copy, I am quite happy to give it to you for free, mate. I have it hidden somewhere (no pun intended)

Expand full comment
Andrew Nette's avatar

Brendan, would happily accept a loan of it, that would be wonderful. Thanks. Please do let me know if you can find it.

Expand full comment
Brendan Long's avatar

I will still have to scour, Andrew. It is not where I thought it was. Have this sinking feeling I may have given it away 16 years ago. But I will persevere!

Expand full comment
Brendan Long's avatar

No worries, Andrew. Will do.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 27, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Andrew Nette's avatar

Hi Andy and thanks for the comment. These discussions are always complex and a bit unwieldy because (a) what is noir and (b) there are so many books out there, you frame a discussion like I have in this post and almost immediately other authors/books appear to disrupt it (which is great BTW). I read Kersh's book ages ago and really liked it. Maurice Proctor's Hell is a City is another book that falls in this territory, although I have not read it. Doubtless there are others.

Expand full comment